10 places to eat in NYC for iconic New York food

This post may contain affiliate links. We may receive a small commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase. Read Disclosure.

Here’s the thing about New York City – there are endless places to eat in NYC and options at every budget level, and most of them are very, very, good.

It’s impossible to eat at every restaurant in New York, and it’s a constantly changing task to confidently say what the “best” restaurants are.

This is simply a list of my favorite places to eat the quintessential New York City classics. These are the places I always bring out-of-towners because I love them, and I hope you do too.

Places to Eat in NYC

Bagels at Absolute

Absolute Bagels - One of the iconic places to Eat in NYC

You can find bagels anywhere in NYC, of varying prices and standards – but Absolute Bagels on Broadway. Oh, Absolute. The bagels are warm and chewy and doughy – the perfect New York City bagel.

The toppings are traditional but varied. The prices are cheap. The line is out the door on the weekends, but the wait is well worth it.

Breakfast at Buvette

Breakfast at Buvette - one of the best places to eat in NYC for iconic NY food.

This French-inspired bistro in West Village is cozy and chic, complete with excellent espresso and an exceptional wine list.

I especially love Buvette for breakfast on weekdays, since it can get quite crowded for weekend brunch: the multi-grain toast with smashed avocado and the yogurt with muesli, fresh berries and honey are both favorites.

Brunch at Freeman’s

Brunch at Freeman’s - one of the best places to eat in NYC for iconic NY food

New York City loves brunch and tucked away in a hidden graffiti-lined alley in the Lower East Side of New York City is fan favorite, Freeman’s

The clandestine restaurant features a horseshoe bar with tasteful taxidermy, complete with homespun American favorites and artisan cocktails.

Spicy chicken sandwiches at The Commodore

Eat a Spicy chicken sandwiches at The Commodore - One of the iconic places to Eat in NYC

Don’t be fooled from the outside, or even the inside. This windowless dive bar in Brooklyn is dark and crowded and loud, and the back courtyard is filled with cigarette smoke and cheap patio furniture.

The service at The Commodore isn’t fantastic. But the spicy chicken sandwiches (and the adult grilled cheese, and the nachos) make up for everything – the food is out-of-this-world delicious making it one of those don’t miss places to eat in NYC! And the ambiance might even grow on you after a while.

I still have friends from California who text me out of the blue reminiscing over the “hot breast” chicken sandwich.

Ruebens at Katz’s Deli

Eat a Rueben sandwich at Katz’s Deli - One of the iconic places to Eat in NYC

The home of “I’ll have what she’s having,” Katz’s is definitely a touristy spot but for good reason. The hand-carved hot pastrami sandwich is as good as it gets.

Ruebens, latkes, pickles, even egg creams: the traditional deli favorites are some of the best that you’ll find.

High Tea at Bergdorf Goodman

High tea at Bergdorf Goodman - One of the iconic places to Eat in NYC

It’s not cheap, but holy moly high tea at Bergdorf Goodman is such a lovely splurge.

With sweeping views over Central Park – best in the heart of changing foliage in fall or right after a heavy snowfall in winter – and pastel-colored fixings, the Bergdorf Goodman restaurant is a fun place to people watch the city’s fabulous.

I especially love high tea on Sunday afternoons, complete with a glass of Veuve Cliquot!

Pizza at Artichoke Basille’s

Artichoke Pizza - One of the iconic places to Eat in NYC
Image: Artichoke Pizza – one of the best places to eat in NYC

You can get a $1 slice of pizza almost anywhere in the city, of varying standards. But Artichoke Basille’s is one of my favorite street joints: it’s open late, and there’s nowhere to sit, but the slices are huge and homemade and tasty.

The special twist is the Artichoke slice: artichoke hearts, spinach, cream sauce, mozzarella and pecorino. Mamma mia!

Cheeseburgers (and beer) at Burger Joint

Cheeseburgers (and beer) at Burger Joint - One of the iconic places to Eat in NYC

I’m a sucker for speakeasies, especially when they involve cheap beer and juicy cheeseburgers.

Located down a dark unmarked hallway off the luxurious Le Parker-Meridien lobby, the unassuming dive bar vibe of Burger Joint feels ages away from the skyscrapers outside. And most importantly, the burgers are cooked to perfection.

Cookies at Levain Bakery

Cookies at Levain Bakery - One of the iconic places to Eat in NYC

A cross between a brownie, muffin, and traditional cookie, each Levain Bakery cookie is six ounces of pure, gooey deliciousness.

The chocolate chip walnut is especially appealing when it’s still warm out of the oven, although I can never finish it while it’s still hot. I like to slowly munch on it on a long walk through nearby Central Park.

Ice Cream at OddFellows

OddFellows Ice Cream - One of the iconic places to Eat in NYC

The flavors at this hipster favorite ice cream joint in Brooklyn are exactly what you’d expect: artisanal and small-batch, the 14 original flavors change daily and range from burnt marshmallow to Thai iced (tea) cream to black pepper fig.

The best part of Oddfellows is the fresh-baked waffle cones: you can smell them as soon as you walk in the door.

More NYC Tips

Top Attractions in NYC

Pre-book your tickets online to New York’s most popular attractions:

Tours of NYC

  • 5 hour Sightseeing tour of NYC – Short on time? Make the most of your stay with this comprehensive 5 hr tour exploring the main attractions with comfortable bus transportation and guide!
  • THE RIDE – a unique tour that is part theatrical show and immersive tour. See classic New York City sights from the comfort of a technologically-advanced moving theater motor coach.
  • Best of New York Circle Line Cruise – 2.5 hour narrated cruise, and the only sightseeing cruise to circumnavigate the island of Manhattan to see the 7 major bridges, 5 boroughs and 101 unforgettable New York sights.
  • Helicopter Tour – Enjoy stunning views of Manhattan Island on a deluxe sightseeing helicopter flight offering 180 degree views from the sky.
  • Harlem Gospel Tour – 4-hour tour of a historic Harlem to experience the thrills of gospel singing, Columbia University and the Apollo Theater before joining a gospel choir for Mass.

Planning a Trip to NYC

Accommodation in New York



Booking.com

Flights to New York

  • Skyscanner is a comparison website that searches millions of flights. Once you find your best deal, book directly through the airline (no extra fees).

NYC Tours & Sightseeing

Find your perfect NYC tours with our preferred partner, Get Your Guide:

Pin Below To Save On Pinterest:

Do you have any tips on places to eat in NYC? Please share in the comments below!

17 thoughts on “10 places to eat in NYC for iconic New York food”

  1. mmm, sandwiches at The Commodore look fantastic.
    If I visit NY, I will have a meal there.
    Thanks for the post 🙂
    Renat

  2. Don’t know if this is iconic NY, but it is for me! I always tell my friends to get Belgian style fries at Pommes Frites on the Lower East Side. Double fried and dozens of great sauces to go with them, can’t go wrong! I try to get there every time I’m home but haven’t had it in a while because there was an explosion and fire in their building some months ago, and their new location hasn’t opened up yet, but it should be soon!

  3. I need to go back to New York! It’s such a great city for foodies. From that list I’ve only been to Oddfellows, so I really need to work on it! In Barcelona it’s really difficult to find a good bagel, I miss the huge tasty ones from NYC..!

  4. Everything looks amazing! I would love to try it but all the foods are junk. Burgers, sandwiches, cookies, ice-cream…

    I prefer European kitchen. Especially, Turkish, Bulgarian, Italian and Greek.

  5. Great food lovers list! We were in New York last year and tried to cram in as many iconic NYC eats as we could! We really loved the Reuben Sandwich at Katz’s Deli..and we also loved Joe’s pizza in Greenwich Village. Simple and delicious!

  6. Wow this makes me want to go back to New York asap! I did a brilliant food tour in Greenwich that made me fall in love with New York food. Katz Deli was great too, but gigantic meal sizes!

  7. Will have to try Pizza at Artichoke Basille’s when I go to Nyc in September, can’t wait for my trip! 🙂

    Aleks

  8. WOW! Awesome tips and ideas on Places to Eat in NYC. As a food lover, I Thank you for very much sharing this valuable information. It is very distinctive and well written.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

4 Powerful Ways to Travel More & Create Better Memories

Want to know how we've made a lifetime of travel for 22 years?

This is what gives us incredible memories to share around the campfire. Join our community for insider tips and updates!

Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid email address.
Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.
Scroll to Top